Summary of Arab Bitcoin meeting with Vincent Carmier and talking about his experience in developing automated trading applications
The content site is one of the sites that provide the service of answering general questions and solving puzzles and crossword puzzles
Where the content site is primarily interested in answering your questions in all areas, including solving puzzles and crossword puzzles
Answer Summary of Arab Bitcoin meeting with Vincent Carmier and talking about his experience in developing automated trading applications
At Bitcoin Arab, we are keen to enrich Arabic content and spread knowledge in the world of digital and encrypted currencies. Within these steps, we hosted the CEO of Karam for Trade and Technology in Arab Bitcoin Group To talk about his experience in developing automated trading applications in the field of digital currencies and financial applications.
- Hi Vincent, First of all I would like to welcome you to our community and thank you again for joining us.
I (Vincent) is a French developer based in Paris and I work in the development of automated trading bots and financial applications. I have an academic background about financial markets as it is my field of study, as I got my first experience in trading in a French bank. I established “Karm Trading Technology” last year, where I developed multiple bots for the following markets (stocks, forex, cryptocurrencies, futures..etc) and automated systems for other tasks related to the trading field such as: (reporting, reference checking, data management). I hope to add new developers to the company soon so we can work on more and more projects! Hello everyone, thank you for inviting me, glad to be part of this community.
Read:Deutsche Bank issues bonds on the EOS blockchain
- To start this meeting, I think the important question we want to ask is that we know that you have a background in financial institutions, but when did your interest in trading and not development begin, and what prompted you to do this?
Well, this interest started towards the end of my academic studies, and programming is not the main thing that is taught in finance but we have some basic classes in “Visual Basic Applications”, then I worked at a French investment bank “Credit Agricole CIB” and there I started developing tools Finance for a team of 10 traders. After that, I went deeper and learned new programming languages. I love the automated part of trading all assets, including cryptocurrencies.
- What is the best programming language for creating a bot?
The answer to this question may vary depending on the type and scope of the project. But 80% of my programs are based on Python, which is a good compromise between efficiency and speed, so this adapts well to most projects that don’t require a lot of computing power. Especially in the cryptocurrency markets, you are more bound by the speed of the connection between you and the trading platforms than the coding speed is.
Read:Coinbase Invests in One of the Latest New Leveraged Bitcoin Trading Platform
For large projects that take up a lot of calculus and a huge amount of data (for the purpose of backtesting, i.e. testing how the strategy worked in the past), C++ is the better programming language but it’s not so easy to do than Python.
- Vincent, can you tell me how to create the best bot strategy to buy low and sell high?
A good start is to get to know what you are currently doing manually in the trading platforms. If you are already trading, you probably already have some strategies in mind. The next step is to think “Can I improve my strategy with a bot?” If the answer is easy, you have to think about why. The reason behind this could be: speed, trading every day every hour, and discipline (the bot sticks to the rules while we humans break those rules sometimes).
- Hi Vincent and glad to be here. Can you give us an example of the bot idea you developed? And what kind of clients do you have now? Is bot trading a better tool than regular trading based on trading rules based on technical analysis or is it connected?
The interesting thing is that I have never developed the same automated trading bot more than once, they were all different from each other, but I worked on arbitrage bots and technical analysis bots (which answers your second question, it is definitely related, and each indicator can be added and programmed) , trend following (for social trading, read another trader’s signal, for example in telegram and have the bot automatically buy or sell when you receive the notification message). My clients are currently individual traders or small businesses all over the world.
Read:Cryptocurrency exchange declares bankruptcy after losing $26 million
- I want to create my own bot using programming, my question is what programming language should I learn? And where do I start?
I would stick to my advice and advise you to learn Python, you will progress quickly but of course you will need some time before you can develop a full bot.
Except for the beginning, I’m not a big fan of online courses. Once you have the basics, set yourself a goal, something you want to create, and get started. You’ll need a lot of things to ask Google at first, but that’s more motivating than just reading the online courses.
- Tell us about “Karm Trading Technology”? What are they and why do they do it?
Karm Trading Technology I provide solutions for other traders to implement their strategies in trading software. What I mean here is that many traders have great ideas, but they don’t know how to program or code and they also need to improve their strategies, which I can help you thanks to my financial background. I don’t sell strategies that are already set up but I can sometimes advise on some improvements to those strategies.
- What data resources do you use for crypto automated trading tools, especially indicators and strategies.
Almost all crypto exchanges offer something called an API (programming interface) to access their data. You can access two types of data: legacy data and streams (streaming data is much rarer), which is what I use in most cases. Trading platforms that offer streaming data are the most convenient to work with because you can’t demand a lot of historical data at the same time so if you need high speed, these won’t suit for that.
- Vincent Another question, were you able to associate TradingView notifications with the automated trading bot? Just need some clues to make it happen.
I once had a project that involved linking with TradingView, but eventually we decided to build everything from scratch because we needed more flexibility, and on top of that, TradingView has its own programming language called “Pine Script” so I didn’t work directly with their alerts, but it is entirely possible to reproduce these alerts outside of their platform.
- Did you add indicators like RSI & MACD to the automated trading bot?
Yes exactly, these indicators can be added quite easily.
- And price points and other data come from the two ways you mentioned that trading platforms provide data?
Yes, so you usually ask for raw data because you need somewhere to start, and then use flow data to update your indicators.
- Have you ever built an AI-based bot that learns and develops its own strategies? If so, can you tell us about it or do you stick to straight signals from the indicators?
I’ve had some projects involving artificial intelligence. You can have simple implementations, using statistics, eg linear/multiple regressions, and the optimization part will be to update your parameters complimenting the new data, so that your model is more accurate thanks to the new data.
Machine learning is the interesting part, and there are many different strategies that can be used with that, but it requires taking on bigger projects, needing more data and more computing power.
- Hi Vincent, I think these strategies are more powerful to use in the stock market. Especially in cryptocurrencies, but we don’t have enough historical data. Can you tell us more about your experience in the cryptocurrency trading market?
Machine learning strategies may be more efficient in the stock market because this market is more liquid and has more historical data already. So, you won’t try to apply machine learning techniques to every cryptocurrency, but I think you can find patterns all over the place, and some highly traded pairs like bitcoin against the dollar. Sometimes in the stock market, which is why stopping losses is so essential.
- What are the security concerns to consider when developing an automated trading bot?
This is a very important question. The trading bot does not need to withdraw funds, so all trading platforms that have an API will allow you to prevent the withdrawal of funds, so that the bot can do trades, request data, etc., but not withdraw funds.
Also there needs to be good communication management. As you know, on some trading platforms the server is down for a few seconds/minutes/hours, and the bot has to take this into account, to detect a lack of connection, for example closing positions.
- You know there are a lot of bots in the market, can you help us how to evaluate and choose the best, what are your tips?
You’re right, I’ve seen many “ready” bots, either for free or for a monthly fee. I think some might work, but my advice would be to think of your own strategy and create your own developer code, so that the result is exactly what you want. I think someone with a successful bot that actually works would keep it for themselves and raise money, not sell it to other people.
- Hi Vincent, I’d like to ask you a few things.
1 – If bots are a successful trading algorithm, why isn’t everyone using them? And what would happen if most of the traders were only using the bot?
2- What are the characteristics of a bot for successful trading?
3- From your experience, what is the average monthly return of a successful trading bot?
1) This is a good comment. My opinion is that bots that really work are not sold publicly. But I would also like to say that I’ve never seen a single bot do exactly the same thing as another. Of course there are some bots that can be placed in the same category, arbitrage bots, technical analysis, etc.. but they all have their own peculiarities.
And if most traders are using the same bots, it would probably be a so-called “self-fulfilling prophecy”: everyone thinks the price will go up, so everyone buys and the price goes up because of it. In this case, only speed is important. I guess you’ve heard of “pumping and dumping”, and it’s the same thing, only the quickest players will get money from this
2) A successful bot will have good data management ensuring that the data is consistent, which is a way to ensure a stable connection with the trading platforms, has adjustable parameters and is able to warn the trader if something goes wrong. These are the basics. I would add that backtesting a strategy through a bot is often helpful.
3) This question is really complicated, I guess it depends on the market. With cryptocurrencies, I think you can get a certain percentage of the profits every day because the differences are big, but the biggest benefit is that it doesn’t depend on you sitting at the computer and doing manual trades. If you have a successful strategy by trading 10 hours a day, you can get more profit by letting the bot do it 24 hours a day.
- If I have an idea of buying a bot in a particular case in selected price ranges, does your bot have a GUI to edit those prices or do you usually edit the bot code itself or do it in other ways?
I design both types of bots, some of them don’t need to update their parameters after they run, but sometimes I create a GUI, which allows you to edit parameters without closing the bot and without editing its code.
- Vincent, I want to have this opportunity and please answer that, how much would it cost if we asked you to develop a bot, and how long should it be ready?
It depends on your strategy, the one you have developed so far. Let’s say at least 2-3 days of work for the simpler and between 2-3 months for the more complex. In terms of price, it also depends on the complexity of the bot, from a few hundred dollars to several thousand for the most complex, I adapt pricing for each project based on its nature.
- Vincent again… these questions are from a member of our community:
1- Can the demo trading software learn the buying and selling prices on its own?
2- Can we program the bot to convert the investment portfolio into a digital dollar (USDT) in the event of a sudden drop?
3- How effective are trading bots in the cryptocurrency world?
1) You have several techniques that you can use for this, it can be the same as you do manually, using technical indicators, historical patterns etc. The point is that instead of being able to watch 2 or 3 indicators for 5 or 6 pairs, the bot can check many indicators on all available pairs, and make a decision faster than you.
2) Yes this is possible, you can program the software to sell cryptocurrency for USDT based on a set of conditions you have chosen (for example, if the price moves by Y in less than X seconds)
3) I would advise you to check some of the answers above, but in terms of speed, a manual trader cannot compete with a bot. Some books move very fast and sometimes it is not possible to check how prices are moving.
*I would like to thank Vincent for answering our questions and it was hard but you did a great job: for our community, you can find Vincent at:
The official website of the company
And you can ask questions on the content site through the word “Ask a question” at the top of the site, where we answer your questions in a short time
